FoundationscardiovascularPhysiology

Heart Sounds: S1, S2, S3, and S4 Explained

Overview

Heart sounds are the audible vibrations of valves closing and blood decelerating — the familiar ‘lub-dub’ of S1 and S2. This lesson explains what generates each sound, why the second sound splits when you breathe in, what the extra S3 and S4 gallops mean, and how murmurs are described. Together with the cardiac cycle, these sounds let you map every audible event onto the mechanical phases of the heartbeat.

Learning objectives

  • Identify the valve events that produce S1 and S2 and state where each is loudest.
  • Explain the mechanism of physiological S2 splitting during inspiration.
  • Distinguish S3 from S4 by timing within diastole and by their associations.
  • Describe a murmur using timing, location, radiation, and grade.
  • Name the five classic auscultation areas and which valve each best reflects.

Process steps

1
S1: ventricular systole begins

As ventricular pressure rises at the start of systole, the mitral and tricuspid (atrioventricular) valves close, and the sudden deceleration of blood against the closed valves vibrates the surrounding structures — the first heart sound, S1 (‘lub’). It is loudest at the cardiac apex, where the mitral component dominates, and it marks the onset of ventricular systole.

2
S2: ventricular systole ends

As ventricular pressure falls at the start of diastole, the aortic and pulmonary (semilunar) valves close, producing the second heart sound, S2 (‘dub’). It is loudest at the base of the heart and marks the end of systole. Together S1 and S2 bracket the systolic interval: every systolic event falls between them.

3
Physiological splitting of S2

S2 has two components: A2 (aortic closure) and P2 (pulmonary closure). During inspiration, negative intrathoracic pressure draws extra blood into the right heart, prolonging right ventricular ejection so P2 follows A2 audibly — the split widens. On expiration the components fuse into a single sound. This respiration-linked splitting is normal.

4
S3: the ventricular filling sound

In early diastole, blood rushing into the ventricle during rapid filling suddenly decelerates against the ventricular wall, producing a low-frequency S3 — the ‘ventricular gallop,’ heard just after S2. It is normal in children, young adults, pregnancy, and trained athletes, whose compliant ventricles fill rapidly; in older adults it suggests the ventricle is handling an abnormal volume load.

5
S4: the atrial filling sound

In late diastole, atrial contraction against a stiff, noncompliant ventricle produces a low-frequency S4 — the ‘atrial gallop,’ heard just before S1. Unlike S3, an S4 in adults is essentially always abnormal and is associated with ventricular hypertrophy or other causes of reduced compliance.

6
Murmurs: the sound of turbulent flow

Any whoosh or rumble beyond S1–S4 is a murmur — the sound of turbulent blood flow through a narrowed (stenotic) valve, a leaking (regurgitant) valve, a septal defect, or simply high flow through a normal valve. Each murmur is described by timing (systolic vs diastolic), location of maximal intensity, radiation, shape, pitch, and intensity on a 1–6 grade scale.

Key variables

VariableUnitTypical rangeRole
S1 timingcardiac phaseonset of ventricular systoleMarks the beginning of systole; produced mainly by closure of the mitral and tricuspid valves as ventricular pressure exceeds atrial pressure. Loudest at the apex.
S2 splitting intervalmilliseconds0–30 fused; 30–60 splitGap between aortic (A2) and pulmonary (P2) closure. Widens on inspiration as increased right-heart filling prolongs right ventricular ejection.
S3 timingcardiac phaseearly diastole, just after S2Low-frequency sound of rapid ventricular filling; normal in the young and athletes, abnormal in older adults with volume-loaded ventricles.
Murmur intensitygrade1–6Grades loudness from barely audible (1) to audible with the stethoscope off the chest (6). Higher grades and diastolic timing more often accompany significant valve lesions.

What makes a heart sound

Heart sounds are brief vibrations caused by the sudden deceleration of blood and the tensing of valve and chamber structures — not by the valve leaflets clapping together alone. S1 and S2 are normal in everyone; S3 and S4 are extra sounds heard in specific physiological or pathological states. Anything beyond these — a whoosh or rumble between or across the normal sounds — is a murmur, the sound of turbulent blood flow.

S1 and S2: the normal pair

S1 (‘lub’) occurs as the mitral and tricuspid valves close at the start of ventricular systole; it is loudest at the apex. S2 (‘dub’) occurs as the aortic and pulmonary valves close at the start of diastole; it is loudest at the base of the heart. Together they bracket systole: S1 starts it, S2 ends it.

Bracketing systole

S1 opens the systolic interval and S2 closes it. Any sound or murmur is described by where it falls relative to this S1–S2 pair — systolic or diastolic.

Why S2 splits when you breathe in

S2 has two components: A2 (aortic closure) and P2 (pulmonary closure). During inspiration, negative intrathoracic pressure draws extra blood into the right heart, prolonging right ventricular ejection so P2 follows A2 audibly — physiological splitting. On expiration the components fuse into a single sound. This normal, respiration-linked splitting is a classic bedside finding.

S3 and S4: the gallop sounds

S3 occurs in early diastole during rapid ventricular filling, when inflowing blood suddenly decelerates against the ventricular wall — the ‘ventricular gallop.’ It is normal in children, young adults, pregnancy, and trained athletes, but in older adults it suggests the ventricle is receiving an abnormal volume load. S4 occurs in late diastole with atrial contraction against a stiff, noncompliant ventricle — the ‘atrial gallop’ — and is essentially always abnormal in adults.

Murmurs: describing turbulent flow

Murmurs arise whenever blood flow becomes turbulent: a narrowed (stenotic) valve, a leaking (regurgitant) valve, a septal defect, or simply high flow through a normal valve. Each murmur is described by timing (systolic vs diastolic), location of maximal intensity, radiation, shape (crescendo, decrescendo), pitch, and intensity on a 1–6 grade scale.

Innocent vs pathologic

Not every murmur signals disease. Thin chest walls, rapid flow in children, pregnancy, and anemia can all produce harmless flow murmurs; timing, grade, and associated findings separate these from murmurs of valve disease.

Where to listen: five classic areas

Sounds are best heard where flow turbulence radiates to the chest wall: the aortic area (right 2nd intercostal space), pulmonic area (left 2nd), Erb's point (left 3rd), tricuspid area (left lower sternal border), and mitral area (apex, 5th intercostal space at the midclavicular line). S2 is loudest at the base; S1 and mitral murmurs are loudest at the apex.

Key points

  • S1 = AV valve closure at the start of systole (loudest at apex); S2 = semilunar valve closure at the start of diastole (loudest at base).
  • Physiological S2 splitting widens on inspiration because extra venous return prolongs right ventricular ejection.
  • S3 is an early-diastolic filling sound — normal in the young, abnormal in older adults.
  • S4 is a late-diastolic atrial sound against a stiff ventricle — essentially always abnormal in adults.
  • Murmurs are turbulent flow sounds described by timing, location, radiation, shape, pitch, and grade 1–6.
  • Innocent flow murmurs occur with high-output states and thin chest walls; not every murmur means valve disease.

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: S1 is the sound of the aortic valve closing.

✓ Truth: S1 is produced by closure of the mitral and tricuspid (atrioventricular) valves at the start of systole. The aortic valve closes at S2, together with the pulmonary valve.

✗ Myth: Any heart murmur means heart disease.

✓ Truth: Many murmurs are innocent — caused by rapid, turbulent flow through normal valves in children, during pregnancy, with fever, or in anemia. Timing, loudness, and associated findings distinguish innocent from pathologic murmurs.

✗ Myth: S3 is always a sign of heart failure.

✓ Truth: S3 reflects rapid ventricular filling and is completely normal in children, young adults, athletes, and pregnancy. Only in older adults does a new S3 suggest the ventricle is handling an abnormal volume load.

Practice questions

Q1. A split S2 that widens during inspiration and fuses on expiration is best explained by which mechanism?
  1. Delayed aortic valve closure on inspiration
  2. Prolonged right ventricular ejection from increased venous return
  3. Premature atrial contraction
  4. Increased left ventricular afterload
Answer: B.

Inspiration lowers intrathoracic pressure, increasing venous return to the right heart. The right ventricle ejects a larger stroke volume over a longer time, so pulmonary valve closure (P2) is delayed relative to aortic closure (A2) — physiological splitting.

Q2. An extra heart sound heard in early diastole, just after S2, in a healthy 22-year-old athlete is most consistent with:
  1. S1
  2. S2
  3. S3
  4. S4
Answer: C.

S3 occurs in early diastole during rapid ventricular filling and is a normal finding in children, young adults, pregnancy, and trained athletes, where compliant ventricles fill rapidly.

Q3. Which statement correctly pairs each normal heart sound with its cause?
  1. S1: semilunar valves open; S2: AV valves open
  2. S1: AV valves close; S2: semilunar valves close
  3. S1: atria contract; S2: ventricles contract
  4. S1: ventricles relax; S2: atria relax
Answer: B.

S1 is produced mainly by closure of the mitral and tricuspid valves as ventricular systole begins; S2 by closure of the aortic and pulmonary valves as diastole begins. Together they bracket systole.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Why can S2 sound like two beats when I breathe in deeply?

Inspiration lowers pressure inside the chest, pulling extra blood into the right heart. The right ventricle takes slightly longer to eject this larger volume, so its pulmonary valve closes audibly after the aortic valve. On expiration the two closures fuse back into one sound — this is normal physiological splitting.

What is the difference between S3 and S4?

Timing and cause. S3 comes in early diastole, just after S2, when blood rushing into the ventricle suddenly decelerates — a ventricular filling sound. S4 comes in late diastole, just before S1, when the atrium contracts against a stiff ventricle — an atrial sound. S3 can be normal in the young; S4 in adults is not.

How are murmurs graded?

On a 1-to-6 scale: grade 1 is barely audible, grade 4 is loud with a palpable thrill, and grade 6 is heard with the stethoscope lifted off the chest. Grade alone does not diagnose anything — timing (systolic vs diastolic), location, and radiation matter just as much.

Can heart sounds be heard without a stethoscope?

S1 and S2 are sometimes audible to the unaided ear in a quiet room, especially in thin individuals, but S3, S4, and soft murmurs are low-frequency and too faint — they require a stethoscope's bell, which is designed for low-pitched sounds.