IntermediatecardiovascularPhysiology
Heart Sounds: Where S1, S2, S3, and S4 Come From
Overview
Heart sounds are brief vibrations produced by valve closure and the sudden deceleration of blood, not by valves opening. The two normal sounds, S1 and S2, mark the beginning of systole and diastole respectively. S3 and S4 are extra sounds that can be normal in some people and abnormal in others. Listening points on the chest wall bring different valve sounds into focus because sound travels through tissue from each valve's location.
Learning objectives
- State the mechanical cause of S1 and S2
- Locate each sound within the cardiac cycle
- Distinguish normal from potentially abnormal S3 and S4
- Explain physiological splitting of S2
- Name the four classic auscultation areas
Process steps
As ventricular pressure rises at the start of systole, it exceeds atrial pressure and the mitral and tricuspid valves close. The sudden halt of blood and vibration of the valve leaflets, chordae tendineae, and ventricular walls produces S1, the first heart sound, heard as 'lub'. Its two components (mitral M1, tricuspid T1) normally fuse into one sound.
During ejection the semilunar valves are open and blood flows smoothly, so no normal sound is generated. Ejection murmurs, when present, indicate turbulent flow and are abnormal findings beyond the scope of this lesson.
When ventricular pressure falls below aortic and pulmonary pressure, the aortic and pulmonary valves snap shut, producing S2 ('dub'). The aortic component (A2) slightly precedes the pulmonary component (P2); the gap widens on inspiration, which is normal physiological splitting.
Rapid ventricular filling can create low-frequency vibrations of the ventricular wall, heard as S3 shortly after S2. An S3 is normal in children and young adults but often abnormal in older adults, where it can reflect a stiff or volume-overloaded ventricle.
Atrial systole pushing blood into a stiff ventricle produces S4, heard just before S1. S4 is almost always abnormal in adults and suggests decreased ventricular compliance, for example from hypertension-related hypertrophy.
Key variables
| Variable | Unit | Typical range | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| S1 timing | cardiac phase | Start of ventricular systole | Marks AV valve closure (mitral then tricuspid); its intensity reflects how forcefully the ventricle contracts |
| S2 timing | cardiac phase | Start of ventricular diastole | Marks semilunar valve closure (aortic then pulmonary); splitting widens with inspiration |
| S3 timing | cardiac phase | Early diastole, just after S2 | Rapid-filling vibration; normal in youth, often abnormal in older adults |
| S4 timing | cardiac phase | Late diastole, just before S1 | Atrial contraction against a stiff ventricle; nearly always abnormal in adults |
| Auscultation areas | chest locations | Aortic, pulmonic, tricuspid, mitral | Each area is closest to where a valve's sound radiates best, e.g. the mitral area at the apex |
Feedback loops
Inspiration splits S2 negative feedback
- Inspiration lowers intrathoracic pressure
- More blood returns to the right heart, prolonging right ventricular ejection
- Pulmonary valve closes later, widening the A2-P2 gap
- Expiration reverses the effect and the sounds fuse again
Sounds come from closure, not opening
A widespread misconception is that you hear valves opening. In reality, opening is quiet because blood accelerates gradually through a widening orifice. Closure is abrupt: a moving column of blood is stopped in milliseconds, and the vibration of blood, valve tissue, and chamber walls is what the stethoscope picks up. S1 is the sound of the AV valves closing; S2 is the sound of the semilunar valves closing.
If you can name which valves close at a phase boundary, you can name the heart sound: S1 = AV valves close, S2 = semilunar valves close.
S1 in detail
S1 has mitral (M1) and tricuspid (T1) components that are normally so close together they are heard as one sound. A loud S1 suggests a forceful ventricular contraction with widely open AV valves at closure; a soft S1 can occur with a long PR interval, where the valves have drifted nearly closed before systole begins.
S2 and its normal splitting
A2 normally precedes P2 because left-sided pressures are higher and the aortic valve closes first. During inspiration, increased venous return to the right heart delays pulmonary valve closure, widening the split; on expiration the split narrows. This physiological splitting is a normal finding and a favorite exam topic.
Fixed splitting, where the A2-P2 gap does not change with breathing, is abnormal and can indicate an atrial septal defect - educational context only.
S3 and S4: the gallop sounds
S3 follows S2 in early diastole and reflects rapid ventricular filling; S4 precedes S1 and reflects atrial contraction into a stiff ventricle. In older adults both are usually abnormal. The S3-S4 sequence with S1 and S2 creates a gallop rhythm. These distinctions are educational; interpreting real heart sounds requires clinical training.
This lesson teaches normal origins of heart sounds. Abnormal findings require evaluation by a licensed professional; do not attempt self-diagnosis.
Where to listen
The four classic areas are the aortic area (right second intercostal space), pulmonic area (left second intercostal space), tricuspid area (left lower sternal border), and mitral area (apex, left fifth intercostal space). Sounds are named for the valve heard best there, not for the valve directly underneath - sound radiates with blood flow.
Key points
- S1 is AV valve closure at the start of systole; S2 is semilunar valve closure at the start of diastole.
- Heart sounds arise from valve closure and blood vibration, not valve opening.
- S2 splits physiologically with inspiration (A2 then P2).
- S3 is normal in the young but often abnormal in older adults; S4 is nearly always abnormal in adults.
- Auscultation areas are named for the valve best heard there.
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: Opening is essentially silent. The audible sounds come from abrupt closure: the sudden deceleration of blood vibrates the valves, chordae, and chamber walls.
✓ Truth: An S3 can be perfectly normal in children, adolescents, and young adults, and in pregnancy, where rapid filling is physiological. Context and age matter.
✓ Truth: S1 (AV valve closure) is loudest at the apex, where the mitral component dominates; S2 (semilunar closure) is loudest at the base.
Practice questions
Q1. S1 is produced primarily by:
- Opening of the semilunar valves
- Closure of the atrioventricular valves
- Opening of the AV valves
- Turbulent flow through the aorta
S1 is the vibration caused by abrupt closure of the mitral and tricuspid valves at the start of ventricular systole.
Q2. Physiological splitting of S2 during inspiration is caused by:
- Delayed closure of the aortic valve
- Delayed closure of the pulmonary valve
- Early closure of the mitral valve
- Opening of the foramen ovale
Inspiration increases right-heart venous return, prolonging right ventricular ejection so P2 follows A2 by a wider gap.
Q3. An S4 heart sound occurs during which part of the cardiac cycle?
- Early diastole, just after S2
- Mid-systole
- Late diastole, just before S1
- Isovolumetric contraction
S4 is generated by atrial systole pushing blood into a stiff ventricle, so it is heard in late diastole immediately before S1.
Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.
Frequently asked questions
What causes the 'lub-dub' of the heartbeat?
Lub is S1, the closure of the mitral and tricuspid valves as ventricular systole begins. Dub is S2, the closure of the aortic and pulmonary valves as diastole begins. Both sounds are vibrations from sudden valve closure, not from opening.
Why does S2 split when you breathe in?
Inspiration increases venous return to the right heart, so the right ventricle ejects slightly longer and the pulmonary valve closes later than the aortic valve. The A2-P2 gap widens on inspiration and narrows on expiration.
Is an S3 always abnormal?
No. An S3 is a normal finding in children and young adults because their ventricles fill rapidly and vibrate. In older adults it more often signals a problem such as volume overload or reduced compliance, which needs professional evaluation.
What is an S4 gallop?
S4 is a late-diastolic sound produced when the atrium contracts against a stiff, noncompliant ventricle. In adults it is nearly always abnormal and is associated with conditions like hypertensive heart disease - educational context only.